Skip to content

Companies potentially stand to receive refunds if Trump's largest tariffs are abolished, yet consumers are unlikely to benefit financially from such a development.

The U.S. President, Donald Trump, takes pride in the substantial revenue generated from the imposed tariffs on imports from numerous nations worldwide. He stated, "We are amassing a fortune equivalent to trillions of dollars," adding, "Without these tariffs..."

Companies may potentially receive refunds if Trump's most substantial tariffs are abolished, yet...
Companies may potentially receive refunds if Trump's most substantial tariffs are abolished, yet consumers would not benefit from such a scenario.

U.S. Tariffs and the Path to Refunds

Companies potentially stand to receive refunds if Trump's largest tariffs are abolished, yet consumers are unlikely to benefit financially from such a development.

In a series of events that have unfolded over the past few years, the Trump administration imposed tariffs on imports from nearly every country around the world. The U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agency has collected over $72 billion in tariffs through August 24. However, consumers would not have recourse to ask for refunds for the higher prices they had to pay.

The process for refunds is not straightforward. Only the importer of record has legal liability for paying tariffs and would be the only one with standing to get the money back. Importers need to have their records in order to successfully claim refunds.

The path to refunds begins with the establishment of the illegality of the tariffs. This could happen through a U.S. court, such as the U.S. Court of International Trade, or, in the case of World Trade Organization (WTO) decisions, through international bodies. If a court decides that certain tariffs were unlawful, it would order CBP to refund the illegal tariffs collected.

CBP is the executing agency and would actually issue the refunds. However, the refund does not occur automatically through international decisions, such as those made by the WTO. The refund is only issued if a U.S. court orders it or if the U.S. government decides politically to do so.

In the case of the disputed tariffs, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has upheld the lower court's decision, but ordered a re-consideration. The Solicitor General has asked the Supreme Court to take up the case and hear arguments in early November. If the Supreme Court agrees, the federal government may have to refund the tariff money collected from companies.

The potential refunds could amount to hundreds of billions of dollars. It's unclear whether the government would have to pay interest on any IEEPA tariff refunds. The refunds would go to the companies that paid the tariffs, not to ordinary Americans. The government may have to establish a system for companies to apply for refunds of their IEEPA tariffs.

The Trump administration might argue against paying back the collected tariffs. Two courts have ruled that Trump's biggest tariffs are illegal. The administration has rolled out tariffs in a chaotic manner, announcing, delaying, or altering them, sometimes conjuring up new ones. There could be a lot of litigation about the nature of refunds and who's entitled to one.

President Donald Trump claims that the tariffs have brought trillions of dollars into the U.S. Treasury. In the 1990s, courts set up a system for exporters to apply for refunds of a harbor maintenance fee. If the Supreme Court rules in favour of the refunds, it could set a precedent for future disputes over tariffs.

In summary, the court or political decision in the U.S. is the key. Without this, there would be no refunds, even if international bodies like the WTO find a violation. The process for refunds is complex and may lead to significant litigation.

Read also: