Skip to content

Italian Authorities Investigate Retro Reviewer for Potential Copyright Infringement Regarding Promotion of Anbernic Handheld Game Consoles, Facing Possible Three-Year Imprisonment for Violations

Italian content creator Francesco Salicini is currently being scrutinized by Italian law enforcement regarding his examination of Anbernic gaming devices.

Italian Authorities Investigate Retro Reviewer for Potential Copyright Infringement by Promoting...
Italian Authorities Investigate Retro Reviewer for Potential Copyright Infringement by Promoting Anbernic Handheld Game Consoles, Facing Possible Imprisonment for Three Years

In the world of gaming, a debate is brewing over the balance between game preservation and respecting intellectual property rights. This debate has recently taken center stage in Italy, where content creator Francesco Salicini is under investigation for allegedly promoting piracy.

The investigation, which is related to advertising Anbernic game consoles, was initiated by the Milan prosecutors. Anbernic consoles are known for emulating classic titles from Nintendo and Sony, and the complaint against Salicini suggests that these consoles often ship with microSD cards containing hundreds of copyrighted ROMs, which is against the law.

The use of emulators for game preservation purposes is a growing concern in the gaming community. As current-generation consoles may not be profitable for developers to keep old games running, the use of emulators is considered necessary to keep these games alive as the hardware designed for them becomes obsolete.

However, the legality of emulators is a complex issue that continues to be debated in the gaming industry. Game studios and game preservation enthusiasts are currently in a debate over the legality of emulators, complicated by the fact that some emulators may still infringe on copyright laws. Developers and studios aim to maintain control over all their titles, even those published decades ago.

Nintendo, known for its protective stance on intellectual property, has taken action against emulators in the past. Thousands of Yuzu emulator repos on GitHub have been taken down, and Nintendo successfully shut down Ryujinx.

The Italian Guardia di Finanza (Financial Police) has seized more than 30 consoles, including those from Anbernic, TrimUI, and Powkiddy, as part of the investigation into Salicini. The police also hold Salicini's phone and transcripts of his conversations with gaming handheld makers.

Salicini, however, claims he only reviewed the hardware and that no manufacturer sponsored his videos. He also refrained from adding affiliate links to his content.

If no action is taken to preserve old games, there is a risk of losing them forever. Emulators are a potential solution to this problem, but the debate over their legality continues. The initial investigation could take up to six months, after which the authorities will decide whether to drop the case or go forward with criminal proceedings.

As the investigation unfolds, the gaming community will be watching closely to see how this debate over emulators and intellectual property rights is resolved.

Read also: