Revising the title: How Should You Adjust Your Narrative?
In the world of writing, Allison Maruska, an author known for her humorous posts, shares insights about teaching, learning, and storytelling. Her posts offer a unique blend of laughter and wisdom, making her a valuable resource for aspiring writers.
When it comes to editing, Maruska emphasises the importance of staying true to one's own story. As she rightly points out, "No one knows a story like the writer themselves, and if a suggestion doesn't feel right for the story, it shouldn't be used."
Professional editors, trained to look for specific literary elements, provide an editing letter outlining major issues and specific notes. Learning to pick out legitimate feedback is essential. However, it's also crucial to thoroughly consider editor suggestions before dismissing them outright.
Having a writing partner during the editing process can be beneficial for decision-making. A critique partner (CP) can offer a fresh perspective, helping to weigh the pros and cons of each suggestion. A questionnaire can also be helpful to gather feedback from betas, who are often non-writers, but their feedback should be considered carefully.
Not all feedback received will be legitimate. Some may be ignored due to defensive reactions or a lack of understanding about the overall story. It's important to consider the source of the feedback, especially from close critique partners. If editor suggestions seem "off" or seem to be from an online editing tool, discussing them with a trusted critique partner can help clarify any confusion.
Joining a critique group as a new writer can be overwhelming, but it's a valuable learning experience. A "Guy In Your MFA" may appear in a critique group, and their suggestions can be ignored if they don't align with the story's vision.
In the end, the editing process involves shaping and reshaping until the final product is the envisioned masterpiece. It's best to wait until all feedback is in before making changes, as this allows for a comprehensive review and consideration of all suggestions.
Remember, the editing process is a collaborative effort, and it's essential to maintain an open mind while staying true to your story. With patience, persistence, and a good critique partner, you can navigate the editing process and emerge with a polished, compelling piece of work.
